Choose the right grade first, then compare nearby pumps. Supermarket petrol is not automatically worse than branded petrol. Both must meet the applicable UK fuel standard, but premium products can differ in octane and additives. In PetrolPal's UK-wide price snapshot synced at 03:18 UTC on 13 October 2026, standard unleaded averaged 172.42p per litre at 1,936 supermarket price records and 175.97p at 2,970 branded records. That 3.55p average gap is about £1.77 for a 50-litre fill. It is not a promise that a particular supermarket is cheaper than the branded station across your road. These changing figures come from our statistics API; see the RAC fuel guide for the distinction between fuel standards and premium claims.
Is supermarket fuel lower quality than branded fuel?
Not simply because of the forecourt sign. The AA identifies BS EN 228 as the UK petrol specification and BS EN 590 as the diesel specification. The RAC says supermarket fuel conforms to the same British Standard as major-brand fuel. Meeting a common specification gives drivers a baseline for the grade sold. It does not mean that all products use the same additive recipe, ethanol proportion or octane rating.
Start by separating three questions. Does the pump sell petrol or diesel? Does its grade meet the car maker's minimum specification? Does an optional premium product offer a benefit you value enough to pay for? A cheap 95 RON E10 pump and an expensive 97+ RON E5 pump are not identical products, even if one is at a supermarket and one has an oil-company logo.
The earlier version of this article treated brand and grade together too often. A supermarket can stock a premium grade; a branded forecourt can sell standard petrol. Treat those as separate comparisons. If you suspect a faulty delivery at a particular station, retain the receipt and report the specific incident. A single incident does not establish that all fuel from one retailer type is bad.
What do E10, E5 and octane mean for your car?
E10 denotes petrol with up to 10% ethanol, and E5 denotes petrol with up to 5%. These labels specify an upper limit, not the exact ethanol content of every tank. The Department for Transport explains that standard 95-octane petrol became E10 in Great Britain in September 2021 and in Northern Ireland in November 2022. E5 remains available as a 97+ octane super grade at most filling stations, but not necessarily every one.
Octane is a different measure. A car specified for 95 RON does not automatically produce extra power or economy just because you buy a higher-octane grade. The RAC says premium petrol can make no discernible difference for many cars. A car whose handbook requires or recommends a higher octane deserves a different decision. Follow the manufacturer's wording, including any instructions about reduced performance on a lower grade.
The Department for Transport says around 95% of petrol-powered vehicles were E10-compatible when it last updated its guidance in November 2022. That is a dated government estimate, not a new 2026 fleet measurement. It says all new cars made since 2011 can use E10, but some older vehicles, motorcycles and specialist machines cannot. Use the government vehicle checker and your handbook instead of assuming compatibility from a registration year alone. An owner of an older E10-incompatible car may need E5 even if standard E10 is cheaper.
The same government guide says E10 may reduce fuel economy by around 1%. Driving style, tyre pressure and other conditions can matter more. Do not confuse an E10-versus-E5 consumption difference with proof that supermarket fuel itself gives worse mileage. Source
How much cheaper was supermarket fuel in the October sample?
Here is a 13 October 2026 grade-for-grade comparison from PetrolPal's UK-wide statistics API. Its last sync was 03:18 UTC. Prices and record counts will change after this sample.
| Grade | Supermarket mean | Branded mean | Difference | 50-litre example |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Standard unleaded | 172.42p, 1,936 records | 175.97p, 2,970 records | 3.55p/litre | About £1.77 |
| Standard diesel | 196.82p, 1,826 records | 201.39p, 2,811 records | 4.57p/litre | About £2.28 |
| Premium unleaded | 184.45p, 1,067 records | 195.44p, 1,573 records | 11.00p/litre | About £5.50 |
These are means of available prices grouped by forecourt type, not matched pairs of nearby stations or a controlled comparison of products. The premium row groups products with different specifications and additive claims; it cannot show that one premium product is equivalent to another. The arithmetic uses unrounded source averages before rounding the table. The differences are illustrative costs of 50 litres, not forecast annual savings. Your tank may take less, and the best station for your journey may be in either group. Source
Our separate public price embed reported 174.2p petrol, 199.7p diesel and 8,175 stations at the same 03:18 UTC sync. Its national totals and aggregates are not the same metric as the detailed statistics API: the latter reported 8,144 stations and 5,414 unleaded price records when retrieved at 04:06 UTC. We do not substitute one series for the other when calculating a supermarket gap. The discrepancy is a reason to name the source and sample rather than present any changing number as permanent. Source
Could the dated average gap add up over repeated fills? Yes, if that gap held for the same grade and your usable local stations throughout the year. It usually will not stay fixed. The previous article projected yearly savings from one August snapshot as though the gap were a reliable annual rate. That estimate is removed. Make your own comparison for the litres you actually buy and the detour you would need to take.
Are additives and premium fuel worth the extra cost?
Different formulas can matter, but a logo alone does not establish a benefit for your car. The RAC describes detergents and other additives in some premium fuels. It does not establish that all ordinary branded petrol cleans an engine better than all supermarket petrol. Nor does meeting BS EN 228 prove every fuel has an identical additive blend.
A manufacturer might specify higher octane for an engine designed for it. In that case, buy the required grade and compare prices within that grade. If the handbook accepts standard 95 RON, a branded premium product is optional. A supplier's cleaning claim is not a guarantee of measurable economy in your vehicle. Ask what the claim was tested against, for how long, and whether it describes your engine. We found no independent UK-wide head-to-head test that justifies a fixed fuel-economy or engine-life advantage for branded fuel as a class.
The premium-unleaded supermarket mean was 184.45p on 13 October, about 12.02p above supermarket standard unleaded in that same snapshot. The grades are not interchangeable for every car; this figure only illustrates the price decision if your car can use both. At 50 litres, that sample difference is about £6.01. It is not evidence that premium will repay its cost. Do not buy a different fuel to treat a fault or ignore a warning light. Source
Does the same advice apply to diesel?
Yes for the basic buying rule: use the grade specified in the handbook and compare that grade locally. The AA identifies BS EN 590 as the diesel specification. Regular and premium diesel products can differ in additives, but a higher pump price does not diagnose or repair a diesel particulate filter problem.
The 13 October sample's 4.57p standard-diesel gap amounts to about £2.28 per 50 litres, before accounting for travel to a station. This is a price-record comparison, not an assertion that one group has better diesel. A diesel driver should check the pump label and the car maker's requirements, just as a petrol driver should check E10 and octane. If a warning persists, seek the proper vehicle check instead of repeatedly changing brands. Source
Why can a branded station beat a supermarket nearby?
National averages hide local competition, motorway convenience, opening hours and the cost of a detour. One supermarket might be cheaper than the brand on a nearby main road, while a different branded site undercuts it across town. The CMA's road fuel market study examined retail competition and found that the identity of the cheapest retailer does not stay fixed. Its historic findings do not certify today's cheapest forecourt or prove anything about fuel quality.
Compare the final cost of a practical stop. For example, a small per-litre saving on 20 litres may not justify a long diversion. Look at the route, the grade, available prices and whether a station is open. A reward scheme only helps if its usable value exceeds a higher pump price; offers and loyalty terms can change. Do not assume a supermarket has the cheapest fuel simply because you already buy groceries there.
Use PetrolPal's fuel-price pages for a nearby comparison and its route planner for possible stops along a journey. Confirm the grade and displayed price at the actual pump before filling. PetrolPal's published snapshot is a changing data feed, not a guarantee that an individual station has just updated its board.
Which pump should you choose?
For a 95 RON E10-compatible car: compare standard E10 at usable local stations. The cheaper practical pump may be a supermarket or a brand. Do not pay for premium solely because you believe a supermarket forecourt cannot sell suitable fuel. The fuel standard, grade and handbook matter more than the name above the shop. Source
For a car that requires 97+ RON or cannot use E10: find the specified E5 or higher-octane grade first, then compare products that meet the requirement. Check the government E10 checker and the manufacturer. An attractive standard-E10 price does not make that fuel compatible. Do not assume every rural station stocks both grades. Source
For a diesel car: compare the appropriate standard diesel across nearby forecourts. Choose premium only if the specification, a clearly evidenced product benefit or your own preference justifies it. Keep price, fuel compatibility and any mechanical problem as distinct decisions. Source
The answer is not a blanket verdict for one forecourt chain. Buy the fuel your vehicle needs, use a dated local price rather than an old national headline, and count the cost of reaching the pump. The 13 October sample makes a case for checking supermarkets, not for ignoring a cheaper convenient brand.



